Pages

Showing posts with label Eric Nenno. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Eric Nenno. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

THe Other View Of Eric Nenno

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Eric Nenno and Texas Clemency

Even in Texas the death penalty is supposed to be reserved for the worst of the worst.

One of the unique aspects of Texas criminal law is a reliance on predictions of future behavior in determining whether or not a person is sentenced to death.  In order for any person to receive a death sentence, all 12 jurors must agree that the individual will represent a continuing threat; a future danger.  Some have likened it to a ticking time bomb, bound to explode.

That charge to the jury, “whether there is a probability that the defendant would commit criminal acts of violence that would constitute a continuing threat to society,” is written into the Texas Criminal Code.

Keep in mind that means being a continuing threat in a prison setting, one of the most secure, locked down environments on the planet.  It means being a danger to cause harm not to the general public, but to other inmates, prison employees and guards.

Eric Nenno assaulted and killed a child in 1995.  When he was convicted in Harris County in 1996, all 12 jurors voted that he would be a future danger, and Nenno was sentenced to death.  He faces a scheduled execution tonight in Huntsville.

But what if that prediction was wrong?

During his pre-trial incarceration in the Harris County jail, Nenno was not deemed to be a danger, and was assigned to tasks assisting guards and others. 

In the 160 months that Eric Nenno has been on Texas death row he has not received a single disciplinary infraction.  He has not been a continuing threat to other inmates or guards.  He has expressed deep remorse for the crime he committed and the void that it has left in the family of his victim.  On death row, Eric Nenno has worked to help others and to resolve conflicts.  He has been respectful to other inmates and his guards. 

Eric Nenno has shown by his actions over the past 12 years that he has not been a continuing threat to those around him.  How does our state’s criminal justice system take that fact into account?

The courts have no judicial remedy for a prediction that turned out to be wrong.  Nor does the Texas Department of Criminal Justice have an administrative process to remove an inmate from death row by virtue of his conduct.  Eric Nenno’s only option was executive clemency.

The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles is the one body with the authority to recommend a commutation of a death sentence to life in prison.  Governor Rick Perry must then approve such a recommendation.

Executive clemency in Texas has been criticized by many criminal justice watchers as failing to live up to its historic responsibility as a failsafe.  The facts of Eric Nenno’s case called out for serious review by the Board.  He has proven on a daily basis over the past 160 months that he has not been a continuing threat.  He has demonstrated that he is not the worst of the worst.  But the Board of Pardons and Paroles rejected Nenno's clemency petition, as noted in this earlier post.

The prediction answered in 1996 got it wrong.  It seems that the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles was not interested in revisiting the question or how to set it right.

This reliance on predictions of future behavior was the subject of Texas Defender Service's, "Deadly Speculation: Misleading Texas Capital Juries with False Predictions of Future Dangerousness."  It was published in 2004.

In 2005, Texas Appleseed and the Texas Innocence Network published, "The Role of Mercy: Safegaurding Texas Justice Through Clemency Reform," which examined best practices in executive clemency.

Comments

Child Killer Executed!

Killer of 7-year-old girl executed in Texas

By MICHAEL GRACZYK Associated Press Writer © 2008 The Associated Press

Oct. 29, 2008, 1:00AM

HUNTSVILLE, Texas — Condemned killer Eric Nenno was the last person 7-year-old Nicole Benton saw when she was abducted, strangled and raped more than 13 years ago.

Her father was among the last people Nenno could have seen Tuesday night when the Texas inmate was executed for killing her and hiding her body in the attic of his home.

Nenno, however, refused to look at Buddy Benton, who stood close to the death chamber window that separated him from his daughter's killer. Nenno also ignored the child's uncle, Donald Benton, and the girl's grandfather, C.J. Bowles, who walked up to the glass to see Nenno, then turned around and stood at the back of the witness area.

Nenno declined to make a final statement from the death chamber gurney.

"No, warden," was his only response when asked by the warden if he had anything to say.

Eight minutes later, he was pronounced dead.

Nenno, a former plumbing supply salesman who lived in the Bentons' neighborhood in Hockley, about 35 miles northwest of Houston, had lured the girl into his home by telling her he needed to get his guitar so he could join a birthday celebration for her father, who played in a band. But once inside, he attacked her, strangled her to keep her quiet, then raped her at least twice after she was dead.

He confessed two days after her disappearance, then led officers to her body.

Nenno became the 13th Texas inmate executed this year and the fourth this month in the nation's most active death penalty state. Another execution is scheduled for Thursday.

Nenno's appeals were exhausted and there were no last-day court actions.

"During the years that I have been imprisoned, I have often thought about the devastating grief and pain I caused Nicole Benton, her family, and her friends," Nenno wrote in a clemency petition that was rejected unanimously by the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles. "There is no excuse nor rationale which would be sufficient to justify this heinous act of violence perpetrated by me."

"He's had a long time on death row," Joan Huffman, the Harris County assistant district attorney who prosecuted Nenno at his 1996 trial, said. "It is frustrating. Eric Nenno had a fair trial and it had been upheld by the highest courts. Beyond any doubt he was guilty of committing one of the most horrendous crimes I'd ever seen.

"I believe we must save the death penalty for those extreme cases and we make sure every constitutional right is upheld and a fair trial is held. But once done, we need punishment. Thirteen years seems like a long time."

In a recent interview from death row, Nenno said he was prepared to die.

"My salvation is secure," he told The Associated Press. "I know where I'm going when this is all over."

Asked where that would be, he replied: "Heaven."

Nenno, born in Olean, N.Y., went to high school in nearby Smethport, Pa., then joined the Navy, where his attorneys said he was exposed to toxic chemicals during a four-year duty tour that left him brain damaged.

Nenno, however, said nothing could excuse his crime.

"I can't apologize enough," he said.

Police investigating the girl's disappearance in March 1995 knocked on his door and when his nervousness attracted their attention, deputies had him accompany them to a command post.

Under questioning, Nenno said he thought she had been abducted, raped and murdered. Asked what kind of person he thought might do such a thing, he replied: "Someone like me."

"I was not cognizant I had committed the crime," he said from death row. "I had blacked out the memory."

He took a polygraph and underwent additional questioning.

"Things kind of fell apart," recalled Anthony Osso, Nenno's trial lawyer.

"I think she's still in the attic," Nenno told detectives, then showed them.

"For the most part, when you confess to elements of an offense, you make it much easier for the state," Osso said. "His statement led them to the body. He himself took them to it."

Nenno told authorities he'd been having sexual fantasies involving young girls for most of his adult life. From death row, Nenno said he was addicted to pornography and had been drinking the day of the slaying.

Huffman said she remembered questioning a medical examiner at Nenno's trial about the girl's fatal injuries.

"That had to be one of the hardest things I've ever done in my life," she said. "The family, they were right in back of me on the front row. I could hear them quietly crying. Some of the jurors were crying. It was heart-wrenching."

The girl's relatives declined to speak with reporters following the execution.

On Thursday, Gregory Wright, 42, was set to follow Nenno to the death chamber. Wright was a homeless man convicted of taking part in the fatal stabbing of Donna Duncan Vick, a sympathetic Dallas County woman who had given him food, shelter and money. Another six Texas prisoners have execution dates for November.